Overcrowding on NEL as allegedly Fewer Trains Operate following disruptions

In the wake of major disruptions that brought the North East Line (NEL) and Sengkang-Punggol LRT system to a halt, train services on the NEL have allegedly been operating with fewer trains than usual, causing overcrowding on trains and stations during the peak hour commute. Power faults caused two disruptions on 12 August and 15 August 2025, stalling train services for hours on the northeastern region. The first incident was traced to a power trip at the Sengkang Rail Depot substation, which supports both NEL and SPLRT, while the second incident was traced to a cable fault between two stations that tripped the LRT network.

Transport blog From the Red Line alleges on a Threads post that the NEL has been operating only 36 out of the usual 39 trains during the morning peak, making a 8% reduction in train capacity. It appears that the train operator is being cautious following the 2 disruptions by operating lesser trains than usual to keep train services running.

Since the publication of this article, SBS Transit has revealed to The Straits Times that 35 out of the regular 40 trains were deployed during the morning peak hours to allow for stable power supply and closer monitoring of the system.

Prior to the disruption, the North East Line has already seen heavily utilization, with the North-eastern towns of Punggol and Sengkang being heavily dependant on it. The Travel Smart Journeys scheme was also introduced on 2 January 2025 to encourage existing NEL commuters to shift their commute to the pre-peak and post-peak periods, or ride City Direct Bus Services or Express Bus Service 43e. 4 New City Direct Bus services were launched on the same day to serve the northeastern region as well. It is to no surprise that a slight reduction of train capacity would result in widespread overcrowding conditions.

In the weeks following the two incidents, netizens have taken to online forums to voice their dissatisfaction over NEL train services. In a Reddit posted dated 19 August, “Is it me or has the commute at NEL gone mad?“, the netizen claims that it takes 2-3 trains to board a train at Hougang station. On 20 August, another Reddit post “What happened to NEL today?” shows a packed platform at Sengkang station, claiming to be unable to board the train after waiting for 3 trains.

An anecdote on the above post also claims:

I took the train at punggol around 7.51am When I went down the escalator queues are already forming for the train towards harbourfront. Usually got queue but also not so long. I thought there was a breakdown. But there is no annoucement so it’s not. Then a train came and people start boarding. Only about 2/3 of the queue managed to board. I saw people nearly clamp by the closing doors. So I took the train towards punggol coast. But at this point the train towards punggol coast seats almost all taken too. When the train got back to punggol. The standing area in the middle of the carriage already quite pack.
It was not like that last Monday. Don’t know where the crowd came from.

On 21 August, another Redditor also posted Serious problems with NEL for last 3 days in morning.

Every morning I take NEL from kovan at 8am.
For the past 3 days there has been a massive crowd waiting to board but we cant.
I usually have had to wait for 5-6 trains to pass by before I could board.
There was no announcement, no news.
Just some staff yelling people to move. But how to move? Online it says normal service . there are huge crowds queueing and we are sweating in our own body heat.
Since there is no announcement or news. It means that this will be the normal in the days to come.
For NEL users, prepared that we have to add 30 mins to our travel time everyday.

A recent post on 25 August also shows a packed train on the NEL, with little space between the standing passengers.

While the current situation is understandably frustrating for commuters, there is reason to believe that these measures are temporary. With the operator seemingly prioritizing caution and safety in the wake of the recent power faults, the reduced train capacity is likely a short-term measure while maintenance and a thorough investigation of the infrastructure are carried out. As the root causes of the disruptions are addressed and the system is deemed stable, it’s highly probable that full train service will be restored, bringing much-needed relief to the daily commute for those who rely on the NEL.

References

16 thoughts on “Overcrowding on NEL as allegedly Fewer Trains Operate following disruptions

  • 29 August 2025 at 12:11 AM
    Permalink

    Goes to show that the introduction of the CDS buses are not worth the resources. They clearly cannot offload the NEL strain, either because people don’t want to switch or because they do not serve the proper areas, or people believe the train is still faster.

    Reply
  • 28 August 2025 at 9:48 PM
    Permalink

    I’m very impressed with how SBST handled the fault. Information came out quickly and updated frequently…Compared to SMRT…

    Also it’s amazing how people complain about a breakdown but don’t give thanks for the 99% of the days the system worked for Singapore.

    Reply
  • 28 August 2025 at 7:30 PM
    Permalink

    So now is it important to have a bus service from punggol coast to Harbourfront?

    After Punggol coast, pls serve Punggol North Ave, there are 2 new bus stop along punggol North Ave! When will more services pass by these sets of bus stops? Including existing bus service can ammend here or new service towards Woodlands, includes Woodlands South. Who is having trouble going Woodlands from no matter Punggol east or punggol drive? Pls voice out so that punggol will have better in transport. Same as well as for Buangkok and Woodleigh, these 2 areas also need improvements. But I kept mentioning Punggol coast as there is SIT there, obviously is important to have more bus services, not only trains we can rely on. Peak hours, we still rely on trains? Buses can be an alternative for those hate squeezing in crowd. Frequency must be better then before.

    Reply
    • 30 August 2025 at 8:52 AM
      Permalink

      Just merge routes 82 and 107 and half the problem is solved. Should have done this long ago.

      Reply
    • 31 August 2025 at 7:08 PM
      Permalink

      Although I don’t live along the NEL, maybe LTA can consider extending service 965 to start from Punggol Coast instead of Sengkang. Please take note that due to the lack of parking lots in WITH and WTBI, you can only amend existing service, but no longer introduce new bus service at Woodlands.

      Reply
  • 28 August 2025 at 4:33 PM
    Permalink

    It’s high time more regular long distance bus services are urgently needed

    Reply
  • 28 August 2025 at 3:54 PM
    Permalink

    Its about engineering. They dont want to over load the electrical system. Probably at the advise of LTA or Singapore Power.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *