60 Electric Buses Procured by LTA

On 24 October 2018, LTA the awarded a contract for the Procurement of Electric Buses (E-Buses) to 3 different tenderers, at a total sum of $50.64 million.

1 20 single-deck electric buses BYD (Singapore) Pte. Ltd. S$17.246 million
2 20 single-deck electric buses ST Engineering Land Systems S$15.148 million
3 10 single-deck and 10 double-deck electric buses Yutong-NARI Consortium S$18.247 million

The 60 electric buses will progressively arrive in Singapore from next year (2019), with the final batch delivered in 2020. Details regarding the depot and bus service allocation for the buses will be announced closer to the implementation date.

Under the scope of the tender, each successful tenderer will also provide charging infrastructure at both bus interchanges and bus depots. Furthermore, the LTA is known to be trialling both cable charging and overhead pantograph charging methods. In contrast with the Hybrid Bus tender (awarded at $28.5 million), the 50 Volvo B5LH buses were procured at a significantly lower unit cost than each of the 60 electric buses (and their charging infrastructure).

Learn more about Electric Buses in Singapore here.

Background

Tender PT323 for Procurement of Electric Buses (E-Buses) was put up by the Land Transport Authority (LTA) on Tuesday, 12 December 2017.

As announced by Second Minister for Transport Ng Chee Meng during the Ministry of Transport’s Committee of Supply Debate in March 2017, the government intended to procure 50 hybrid buses and 60 electric buses in 2017. This allowed the LTA to expand its trial of such “green” vehicles, which while environmentally-friendly, were more costly and less suitable for the island’s tropical climate. Electric vehicles operating in Singapore consume a lot of energy for air-conditioning, and their batteries and/or hybrid systems work less efficiently in our warm and humid environment.

The Diesel Hybrid bus tender was awarded to Volvo earlier this year. The manufacturer will deliver Volvo 7900 Hybrid buses which are expected to enter service starting from the second half of 2018.

Upon procuring the Electric Buses, the Land Transport Authority will allocate the buses to the Bus Operators (SBS Transit, SMRT Buses, Tower Transit, Go-Ahead Singapore) to operate on selected bus services. Currently, a large majority of LTA’s bus assets are Euro V compliant Diesel buses.

A battery-powered all-electric bus had previously been trialled locally by a Public Transport Operator. Between November 2016 and May 2017, a BYD K9 bus was operating with Go-Ahead Singapore under an LTA-initiated trial. Previous trials in Singapore have involved diesel-hybrid buses such as the Sunlong SLK6121UF14H, and Zhongtong LCK6121G HEV, and Volvo B5RLE Hybrid.

BYD K9:

Tender submissions closed on 23 April 2018 at 4:00PM after 2 extensions.


Tenderers

As of the tender closing time, 10 bids were submitted. As part of the tender evaluation process, the LTA took into consideration the track records of the firms, their technical capabilities, adherence to requirements and compliance with local regulations.

S/No Tenderer Price
1. BYD Singapore Pte. Ltd. S$17,246,317.00 (20 SD)
S$16,461,747.00 (20 SD Base)
2. CaetanoBus – Fabricacao de Carrocarias S.A. S$23,149,720.00 (20 SD)
3. Cycle & Carriage Industries Pte. Limited Not Shortlisted
4. ST Engineering Land Systems
(Bidded as: Singapore Technologies Kinetics Ltd)
S$15,148,400.00 (20 SD)
S$13,826,400.00 (20 SD Base)
S$16,956,400.00 (10 DD + 10 SD)
5. Tron Energy Technology Corporation Not Shortlisted
6. Volvo East Asia (Pte) Ltd S$28,829,756.00 (20 SD)
7. Yutong-NARI Consortium
(Bidded as: Zheng Zhou Yu Tong Bus Co., Ltd.)
S$18,246,523.70 (10 DD + 10 SD)
S$17,287,513.70 (20 SD)
S$19,205,533.70 (20 DD)
8. Zhongtong Bus Holding Co., Ltd. S$18,198,862.00 (20 SD)
9. Zhuhai Granton Bus And Coach Co., Ltd. Not Shortlisted
10. Zhuhai Guangtong Automobile Co., Ltd S$15,871,872.00 (20 SD)

Based on the tender award, LTA picked an alternate bid from ST Engineering that was $1.3 million higher than its quoted base price. Similarly, LTA had gone for an unknown option that increased the cost of the BYD tender by almost $800,000 (which was not reflected in the list of BYD’s alternate bids).


Bus Models

The specific models of electric buses brought in by the successful tenderers will be announced in the future.


See Also
External Links & References:

Back to Bus Articles





2 thoughts on “60 Electric Buses Procured by LTA

  • 8 November 2018 at 4:02 PM
    Permalink

    There’s some additional information :

    The ST Engineering ones will be Linkkers, similar to the autonomous ones.
    According to the tender, ST Engineering will also install chargers at Bedok and Bukit Panjang interchanges, so the Linkkers will probably serve those areas.

    The BYD ones will go to either one of these 3 choices:
    1. Seletar depot
    2. Loyang and Woodlands depot (10 each)
    3. Bulim depot

    Reply
  • 8 November 2018 at 4:01 PM
    Permalink

    There’s some additional information :

    The ST Engineering ones will be Linkkers, similar to the autonomous ones.
    According to the tender, ST Engineering will also install chargers at Bedok and Bukit Panjang interchanges, so the Linkkers will probably serve those areas.

    The BYD ones will go to either one of these 3 choices:
    1. Seletar depot
    2. Loyang and Woodlands depot (10 each)
    3. Bulim depot

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *